59% of UK adults oppose AI personalized appeals from charities

YouGov research published Thursday found that 59% of UK adults oppose AI personalized donation appeals, even though the public is more open to charities using AI for staff tasks behind the scenes. YouGov says the findings show people draw a clear line between AI as an internal efficiency tool and AI as a voice speaking directly to supporters.

Staff support draws the most acceptance

YouGov surveyed 2,097 UK adults online on Aug. 19 and 20, with results weighted to represent all adults in the country, and it found the public most accepting of AI that supports charity staff. Two in five adults (42%) say it is acceptable for charities to use AI to summarize research or reports for staff and volunteers, compared with 32% who call it unacceptable.

Using AI to help staff write grant applications drew a similar response, with 38% calling it acceptable and 33% calling it unacceptable. Some funders already apply AI to internal grantmaking operations, which matches the type of use the survey found people most willing to accept.

Public resistance grows for charities using AI in appeals

Acceptance falls once AI moves into public facing content, with about 45% of adults saying it is unacceptable for charities to use AI to draft fundraising emails or generate campaign images, compared with 28% who find it acceptable. Writing social media posts and website content draws a similar split, with 47% opposed and 26% accepting.

Resistance is strongest where AI could shape how donors are targeted or how beneficiaries are represented, and 69% reject fictional stories or images showing the types of people a charity helps, while only 12% accept them. Personalized appeals based on a donor’s previous giving draw 59% opposition and 14% acceptance, and AI generated narration or visuals in videos meet 58% opposition and 16% acceptance.

Stories based on the real experiences of people a charity has helped fare slightly better, with 31% finding them acceptable if someone checks the content, although 44% still object. Elsewhere in the sector, projects such as an AI platform for dog adoption aim to keep the human connection at the center of the process.

Adults aged 25 to 54 are generally more receptive, while those aged 18 to 24 and 55 and over are more resistant, and the oldest group stands out for opposing personalized appeals (63%) and fictional stories or images (73%). YouGov says UK adults value transparency and expect charities to apply the same principle to new technologies, which leaves staff facing uses with the least resistance and donor facing uses with the most.

Stay informed on nonprofit news, grants & jobs

Join sector leaders and grantmakers who read Charity Journal.

Read more

Charity 101